All Challenges

Employees

My Employees Don't Know What Success Looks Like

Give each role a clear scorecard so people know what good looks like.

The Challenge

Give each role a clear scorecard so people know what good looks like.

Why This Happens

  • No written expectations
  • Expectations change
  • No measurement or reviews

Questions to Ask Yourself

  1. 1.Could each employee describe their top three responsibilities?
  2. 2.Do they know how they're measured?
  3. 3.When was their last review?

What to Do First

1

Write a scorecard for one role.

2

Review it with the employee.

3

Set a review date.

Step-by-Step Solution

  1. 1

    Role purpose

  2. 2

    Top responsibilities

  3. 3

    Expected results

  4. 4

    KPIs

  5. 5

    Weekly expectations

  6. 6

    Who they report to

  7. 7

    Decision authority

  8. 8

    Review frequency

Three Levels of Solutions

Quick Win

Do this today

Write the top three responsibilities for one role.

Build the System

Next 30 days

Create a scorecard for every role.

Long-Term Transformation

Where you're headed

A team that knows what success looks like.

Lessons From the Pass It On Library

From The Servant

Clear expectations are a form of respect.

Framework: Leadership Self-Check

From Traction

Every seat has clear accountability.

Framework: Vision · People · Data · Issues · Process · Traction

Pass It On Action

Review a scorecard with one employee.

Practical Tool

Employee Role Scorecard

Fill it in here, then download or print. Your answers stay on your device.

Your Action Plans

Sign in to check off steps and save progress to My Growth Plan. Sign in

7-Day Action Plan

  • Day 1 — Identify the problem: write down exactly how “My Employees Don't Know What Success Looks Like” shows up in your business.
  • Day 2 — Review the numbers: gather the facts, figures, and examples connected to this challenge.
  • Day 3 — Find the root cause: answer “Could each employee describe their top three responsibilities?”
  • Day 4 — Choose one change: Write a scorecard for one role.
  • Day 5 — Assign responsibility: name ONE owner, a deadline, and the expected result.
  • Day 6 — Implement: Review it with the employee.
  • Day 7 — Review what happened: what worked, what didn’t, and what you’ll do next week.

30-Day Action Plan

Week 1 — Diagnose

  • Answer: Could each employee describe their top three responsibilities?
  • Answer: Do they know how they're measured?
  • Answer: When was their last review?
  • Complete the 7-Day Action Plan.

Week 2 — Build

  • Create a scorecard for every role.
  • Role purpose
  • Top responsibilities
  • Expected results
  • KPIs

Week 3 — Implement

  • Weekly expectations
  • Who they report to
  • Decision authority
  • Review frequency
  • Train the people involved and assign owners.

Week 4 — Measure & Improve

  • Compare results to where you started.
  • Write one lesson learned.
  • Adjust the process.
  • Share what you learned with someone in the fellowship.

Biblical Principles

Wisdom for the journey — encouraging stewardship, integrity, and service, never a promise of guaranteed success.

#22 · Leadership

Great leaders carry responsibility

Matthew 20:26–28

#54 · Employees

Treat employees with dignity

Colossians 4:1

#55 · Employees

Encourage your team

1 Thessalonians 5:11

See all Biblical Principles

Related Challenges

Recommended Books

Approved Bookshelf resources related to this challenge.

Traction cover
Systems

Traction

Gino Wickman

A practical operating system for growing past the owner's limits.

Recommended for: My Employees Don't Know What Success Looks Like

Pass It On may earn a commission when you purchase through certain links on this site, at no additional cost to you. These commissions help support the mission and programs of Pass It On. Read the full disclosure.

Still Stuck? Ask the Community

Tell us what you are facing, what you have tried, and what outcome you want.

Sign In to Ask for Help

How Others Solved This

Real lessons from Pass It On members, shared after administrator review.

No member stories yet for this challenge — yours could be the first.

Share how you solved it

Protect confidential information: no customer names, employee details, addresses, pricing, contracts, or financial records.

Sign In to Share

You don't have to build alone.

Challenge → Diagnose → Prioritize → Learn → Take Action → Measure → Improve → Help Someone Else

Learn it. Apply it. Pass it on.

Learn It. Do It. Pass It On.

Stronger People. Stronger Businesses. Stronger Communities.

Join The Movement